Kalani Sitake Stays with BYU, Rejects Penn State Offer Amid Talks

UPDATE: In a stunning turn of events, Kalani Sitake will remain the head coach of BYU, officially rejecting an offer from Penn State. This decision comes after intense discussions regarding the open head coaching position at Penn State, as confirmed by ESPN.

Sitake, who has led the Cougars for over a decade, has agreed to a lucrative contract extension that is expected to include significant commitments for his coaching staff, including offensive coordinator Aaron Roderick and defensive coordinator Jay Hill. The new deal is reportedly worth around $11 million over multiple years, showcasing BYU’s commitment to retaining its successful coach.

This announcement arrives just days before BYU’s crucial game against No. 5 Texas Tech in the Big 12 Championship on December 2, 2025. As the Cougars prepare for this pivotal matchup, Sitake is making it clear that his future lies in Provo, even informing Penn State officials of his decision.

Fans and players alike are celebrating the extension, with BYU defensive back Evan Johnson declaring, “Yes, yes, yes; he’s the best coach in the nation,” following the team’s impressive 41-21 victory over UCF. The extension not only solidifies Sitake’s role but also enhances BYU’s reputation as a rising force in college football.

While the details of the deal are still emerging, sources indicate that it will also include investments in name, image, and likeness opportunities for players, further strengthening the program’s competitive edge. This move comes as BYU has demonstrated significant success under Sitake, boasting an 83-44 record during his tenure, including an 11-1 season in 2025.

Prominent donors, including leaders from major corporations like Nutricost and Crumbl, have rallied behind Sitake, ensuring that BYU maintains its competitive standing in the college football landscape. With Sitake’s departure from consideration for the Penn State role, the Cougars can now focus entirely on their championship aspirations.

As the situation unfolds, all eyes will be on BYU as they gear up for their championship game, with Sitake’s renewed commitment heralding a new chapter for the program. Fans can rest easy knowing that their beloved coach is here to stay, ready to lead the Cougars into the future.

Stay tuned for more updates on this developing story.