The United States National Team Development Program (USNTDP) emerged victorious against the Canadian Hockey League (CHL) in an exhilarating match at the 2025 CHL-USHL Prospect Challenge. This marked the first time in the event’s history that the game went into super overtime, where Victor Plante scored the decisive goal, evening the series at one win each after the CHL had dominated the previous year.
The series not only showcased intense competition but also highlighted several players whose performances may significantly influence their draft stock for the upcoming NHL draft. The event, recognized as one of the premier prospect showcases of the year, saw discussions ignite around the best defensemen in the draft class, with multiple standout players solidifying their reputations.
Defensive Stars Shine Bright
Among the most notable performances was Xavier Villeneuve, a 5-foot-11 defenseman who many observers deemed the most impactful player for the CHL. His exceptional skating ability and edgework allowed him to evade pressure effectively, contributing significantly to offensive plays. Villeneuve exhibited a mix of physical engagement and offensive creativity, drawing comparisons to NHL stars like Quinn Hughes and Lane Hutson.
The question of whether this draft class is the year of the defenseman became increasingly pertinent. In addition to Villeneuve, other defenders also impressed scouts. Daxon Rudolph provided reliable, defensive stability, excelling in puck retrieval and transitional plays. Carson Carels demonstrated efficiency and effectiveness, making smart plays and creating advantages on both sides of the puck.
Furthermore, Chase Reid, often debated as the top blueliner in the draft, showed flashes of brilliance despite some early mistakes. Reid’s ability to create scoring chances and join offensive plays adds to his appeal, but consistency will be key as he moves forward.
Dynamic Smaller Forwards Make Their Mark
The series also turned conventional beliefs about smaller forwards on their heads, as players standing at 6 feet or shorter delivered standout performances. Mikey Berchild, Wyatt Cullen, JP Hurlbert, Mathis Preston, and Plante consistently attacked with speed and skill, creating chaos for defenders.
Cullen, in particular, showcased an impressive ability to win puck battles, demonstrating that size does not define a player’s capability. His relentless pursuit and ability to generate turnovers led to significant scoring opportunities. Despite an injury in the second game, his impact remained felt.
Berchild also excelled, highlighted by a remarkable assist that set up the opening goal in Game 1. His high-end puck skills and playmaking ability demonstrated his potential as a middle-six forward in the NHL.
Plante’s super overtime goal not only clinched the series for the U.S. but also underscored his energetic playing style. His speed and intensity were vital to the team’s success, despite challenges against larger opponents.
Goaltenders Make Strong Cases
In the crease, Brady Knowling and Harrison Boettiger proved instrumental for their respective teams. Boettiger’s performance in Game 1 was crucial for the CHL, where he kept the game competitive as the team adjusted to the pace. In contrast, Knowling emerged as a key player for the U.S. in Game 2, demonstrating impressive rebound control and athleticism.
Both goalies showcased their potential, solidifying their positions as sought-after prospects in June’s draft.
Future Stars Emerge
While the focus primarily lay on players eligible for the upcoming draft, Sammy Nelson, a player eligible for 2027, made a significant impression. His strong two-way play, physical engagement, and exceptional instincts positioned him as a player to watch in the coming years.
In addition, Caleb Malhotra and Alessandro Di Iorio elevated their draft stock through their performances. Malhotra’s leadership qualities and ability to deliver in crucial moments earned him praise, while Di Iorio showcased his offensive potential alongside a strong physical presence.
The series brought to light the depth of talent available in both the CHL and USHL, raising discussions about future formats. Many observers noted that the U.S. team, predominantly comprised of NTDP players, might benefit from including a broader selection of USHL talent to enhance competition.
The thrilling matches of the 2025 CHL-USHL Prospect Challenge not only entertained but provided a platform for emerging talents to spotlight their skills ahead of the NHL draft, promising an exciting future for hockey enthusiasts.
