Research Uncovers Role of Broken Promises in Quiet Quitting

The trend of “quiet quitting” has gained significant attention, with reports indicating that at least 50% of the U.S. workforce engaged in this behavior in 2023, according to data from Gallup. This phenomenon involves employees fulfilling only the minimum requirements of their job, leading to a shift in workplace dynamics. New research from Bowling Green State University delves into the underlying causes of quiet quitting and offers insights into how human resources departments can enhance employee engagement.

In a study led by Truit Gray, an assistant professor at the BGSU Schmidthorst College of Business, findings suggest that employee perceptions of promise fulfillment significantly influence their engagement levels. When employees believe that their organization has upheld its commitments regarding job characteristics—such as skill variety and autonomy—there is a marked decrease in quiet quitting behaviors. The research indicates that fulfilling these promises not only reduces the likelihood of quiet quitting but also promotes positive organizational citizenship behaviors, such as mentoring new hires and undertaking additional responsibilities.

Conversely, when organizations fail to meet these expectations, employees are more inclined to quiet quit. This disengagement can lead to increased counterproductive work behaviors, which can harm the overall effectiveness and culture of the workplace. As Gray emphasizes, the consequences of broken promises extend beyond individual dissatisfaction; they can adversely affect organizational performance and morale.

The study suggests that human resources professionals need to adopt a more proactive role in addressing employee needs and fostering a culture of trust and accountability. By actively engaging with employees and ensuring that promises are kept, organizations can create an environment where employees feel valued and motivated to contribute positively.

This research has been published in the journal Human Resource Management, highlighting the importance of psychological contracts in the workplace. The findings stress the necessity for organizations to recognize the impact of employee perceptions on engagement and productivity.

As the issue of quiet quitting continues to impact various industries, the insights from this research serve as a crucial reminder for employers to prioritize nurturing a positive workplace culture. Addressing the gap between employee expectations and organizational realities could prove vital in reversing the trend of quiet quitting and enhancing overall workplace satisfaction.