UPDATE: Two people have tragically lost their lives in a shocking stabbing incident at the A&A Italian Deli and Pizza in Bethpage, NY. The violent act occurred just after 9 a.m. on December 4, 2025, prompting a rapid response from Nassau County police and emergency services.
Authorities confirm that a male suspect is now in custody, with further details expected during a briefing scheduled for Thursday afternoon. Witnesses describe a harrowing scene, as panic unfolded in this beloved local establishment known for bringing families together for over 30 years.
Witness Joe Boros recounted the chilling moment, stating, “He walked out and he said ‘I stabbed my parents.’ Nonchalantly walked out … I just don’t understand.” The emotional impact of the incident was felt deeply within the community, as friends and patrons consoled each other outside the deli.
Resident Alicia Garbanero expressed her heartbreak, saying, “They were absolutely wonderful. The entire community knows this deli. Everyone loves the family. Just kind, funny, good, old-fashioned Italian family. Everyone loved going in there. The food was great. It’s heartbreaking.”
This tragic event has sent shockwaves through the local community, highlighting the close-knit ties that have been shattered by this act of violence. As police continue their investigation, they are urging anyone with information to come forward.
Stay tuned for updates as this story develops. More information will be provided following the police briefing later today.
